Author Archive

Ive been a big fan of Vir Sanghvis writing for years, and am glad to see he is one of the first prominent Indian Journos to dip their feet on the web.

However I am also terribly disappointed in the technology of the site, not the content but the technology. I am no open source zealot, most of the work our company does has Microsoft technologies behind it and I’m a big fan of the .NET platform in general. However I do also believe that every job has the right tool, and in this case by using a .NET based CMS Vir Sanghvi has done himself a disservice. Based on the sites content an implementation of Wordpress or Joomla would have been much easier(and dare I say much less expensive), and provided the content in a far superior way.

Some specific problems:

1. The RSS feed is just wrong. The data in the feed has nothing to do with the page linked to.

2. The next page link uses an AJAX control that does not take you to the top of the next page.

3. The form for Lets Talk does not work.

virsanghviletstalk

Lets hope these are teething issues, but my experience has been that for content focused sites Open Source CMS’s do a better job.

What the ….???

I saw a medianama post about internet penetration in India. Nikhil has some good analysis but I disagreed with one point.

Percentage growth: In percentage terms, Maharashtra grew the least, followed by Delhi and Tamil Nadu, primarily because of the large subscriber base.

I think growth in Maharashtra lags because of pricing. An unlimited 256K connections going to cost you close to a Thousand bucks. I pay VSNL about 1100. My cable guy offers me something for 800 but I promised never to use IN Cable for internet ever again an I intend to follow through on that.  MTNL offers one for 2500. I just thought I would compare prices between MTNL Mumbai and MTNL Delhi and was shocked. I knew there was a price difference but this is ridiculous.

Mumbai:

Mumbai

Thats Rs. 2500 for a 256K, 4500 for a 512K

Compared to Delhi:

delhi

Thats Rs. 599 for a 256K and 1299 for a 512K. Thats half the price for twice the bandwidth.

Are you fucking kidding me? Can anyone come up with a logical reason for why thi might be the case?

Police Modernization PIL

UPDATE:  An email id has been provided. savemumbai@in.com
Email this address with in case they need to show citizen support in court.

There are a lot of questions being asked about how the recent terrorist attacks in Mumbai could take place. Most of this seems like noise rather than any sort of concrete measure to improve security. A friend of mine has been involved with a PIL that is asking for an accounting on why numerous police modernization initiatives have gone nowhere. The Society of Indian Law Firms(SILF) and the Bombay Chamber of Commerce and Industry are both involved as well.  In my mind this kind of PIL is far more productive than the abstain from voting, tax revolution, bomb Pakistan nonsense that is being forwarded on the internet and over sms’s.

The filing of the PIL got some coverage in the press but not enough. Here are some articled from Mint, Indian Express and DNA. This is not the flashy emotional appeal that the majority of the press seems to lap up. This is a substantive series of steps we would like our government to take and consequently the amount of coverage is limited.

My friend has asked me to help get the word out, and try and get as many people as possible to sign up here.

So what can you do?

First and foremost I would appreciate it if you could pass this message on as far and wide as possible. The more people who sign up for this the better. At the bottom of this post there is a little share this button. You can use that to email this post, or share it with anyone you would like to. Pass it through facebook, through orkut, through twitter anyway you can think of getting this in front of as many people as possible. There is a forum on the website www.abillionhands.com Its not very active right now but maybe we can change that.

Next step would be to take this out of cyberspace and into real life. I have some ideas for things we can do, but lets see how many people we can get to work on this.

If you would like to read the full text of the PIL you can download it from here.

Below is a Background Note about the PIL.

It has happened before and it could happen again. Mumbai has been attacked by terrorists over 15 times in the last 2 decades and by virtue of it’s position as the country’s financial capital, is a prime and vulnerable target for future attacks.

26/11 has yet again exposed the many weaknesses in Mumbai’s security systems. The audacious attack on 2 of Mumbai’s leading hotels and it’s key railway station has led to a tremendous loss of civilian and police lives and great damage to property. The anger and anguish amongst Mumbaikars is palpable. This time it cannot go to waste – it has to be channelised towards effecting constructive change for the City.

Mumbai has a more than 16 million strong population and just 42,000 policemen & women. Festivals, floods, fighting crimes and terrorist attacks…Mumbai’s brave police men and women put their lives on the line everyday. They help keep the wheels of India’s financial capital turning – but what have we done to help them?

Now the Society of Indian Law Firms, that represents India’s leading law firms, supported by a large group of leading business personalities in Mumbai and the Bombay CHamber of Commerce & Industry believe it’s high time Mumbai did something for it’s Police.

PIL : WHO & WHY?

- The Petitioner is the Society of Indian Law Firms supported by a group of concerned Mumbai citizens and business leaders from the City. On Thursday, India’s oldest chamber of commerce, the Bombay Chamber of Commerce & Industry joined the PIL. The Bombay Chamber has over 2000 member companies. It is for the first time in the Bombay Chamber’s history that it is backing citizen action of this sort.

- More training, modern equipment, better coordination, enhanced resources and an elite force that can deal promptly with terrorist attacks – the solutions are all known, discussed and debated. In many cases the State has even promised to implement measures to help better equip the Police. But little has come of it.

- Now the only option is to seek Court assistance in ensuring that all measures are taken to assist the Police in being better equipped to deal with the threat of 21st century terrorism

-The judiciary is the last standing pillar of democracy. Whenever all else has failed, the courts have come to the rescue of citizens – be it pertaining to the Environment, Heritage, Law & Order or Road Safety…

PIL has been a very effective tool used by Citizens to have their voices heard

- And so the SILF, Bombay Chamber and it’s supporting citizen team are now appealing to the Court to help ensure the State assists in modernising Mumbai’s Police

PIL: DETAILS

The PIL requests the Bombay High Court to direct the Union & the State (both, either/or wherever applicable)

a) Pursuant to the guarantee of ‘right to life’ in Article 21, the Union & the State should take all appropriate measures to meet the security threat to Mumbai

b) To disclose via affidavit all concrete steps being taken, with timeline and funding particulars, regarding establishment of Special Squad (Quick Response Team has been put together but not fully empowered)

c) Alongwith the above 2 points a) & b), the Union/State should

1. Permanently station NSG unit in Mumbai and wherever else required in Maharashtra

2. Provide sufficient coastal security coverage

3. Establish coordination mechanisms across Intelligence agencies, State Police and all Security Agencies

4. Assist, train and equip Police to meet new age terrorist threat

d) Alongwith a), b) & c), the Union/State should

1. Formulate and implement Crisis Management Plan

2. Procure and provide adequate equipment/vehicles/machinery (including Marine & Chopper units) for quick mobility via land/sea/air for effective patrolling, prevention and containment of crime/terrorist attack. This should be reserved for Police duties

3. Identify, fund and provide Surveillance Gear (such as CCTV coverage)

4. Implement the McKinsey Report that studied the Mumbai Police and advised on improvement and modernisation

e) Appoint Citizen Committee comprising of eminent citizens, retired judges and police officers to assist and advise on the implementation of all these measures.

Monsoon Reading 2008

ReadingintheRain I am a huge fan of fantasy literature, and have had a fantastic couple of months of reading. The monsoon is one of my favourite times to do some hardcore reading. If its raining on a weekend, I can go 8-10 hours in a day no problem.

Brief reviews of some of the books read this monsoon follow:

Spirit Gate by Kate Elliot (3.5/5)

I liked the concept of the Eagle riding Reeves. It promises to be a much larger story than what we have seen so far, and I am very much looking forward to the rest of the books. This had the feel of setup.

Mistborn by Brandon Sanderson (5/5)

This was awesome. Just awesome. I am so glad this is the author finishing up Robert Jordan’s Wheel of Time. Most visual and exciting magical system I can remember reading about. I’ve always thought for Fantasy to be good, Magic needs to be logical. Wave your hand and crazy shit happens is not fun. This is as detailed, as “scientific” as I can imagine a magical system be.

Orphans of Chaos by John C. Wright (3/5)

I don’t like it when its tough to keep track of who is who. For a book as short as this was, it seemed unnecessarily confusing. Every character has at least a couple of names, which are used interchangeably. This annoyed me to the point where it took away from my enjoyment. This was disappointing, as the story seemed funny. It was a set up book, and Im not sure if I would seek out the rest of the books.

Through Wolf’s Eye’s by Jane Lindskold (4/5)

The first book of the Firekeeper series. Reminiscent of David Eddings style. Lots of humor. Simple Story. A little cliched, but using cliche as short hand, rather than filler. Unforgettable characters in Lady Blysse and Blindseer.

Little Brother by Cory Doctorow (4.5/5)

I am not a big fan of Doctorows non fiction writing. I agree with a lot of his basic ideas regarding Open Source, DRM etc. but he is an absolutist when it comes to these issues  and can come off as condescending. I thought his slamming audible.com for DRM on the This Week in Tech podcast, (during an audible ad no less!) was in extremely poor taste. That stridency has helped with this book though. Its set in the world of tomorrow and is the story of how a couple of kids get caught up in a Homeland Security roundup, how badly they are treated and how they get their revenge. It has interesting rants on privacy, burritos, xboxes, and biometrics among other issues of the day.

Mistborn 2: The Wells of Ascension (4.5/5)

Second book in the Mistborn Trilogy by Brandon Sanderson. I didn’t enjoy it quite as much as the first book, but it was a fun read. More political, than the action kung fu style of the first book. In this volume we see how Vin grows into her power. There is an incredible set piece, where Vin goes berserk and causes an unholy amount of destruction. We have been often told but for the first time in this series we really understand how powerful Mistborn are.

The Lies of Locke Lamora by Scott Lynch (5/5)

Funniest, bloodiest, goriest, book I’ve read in a long long time. Locke Lamora is the leader of a gang called the Gentleman Bastards (Love that gang name, I will use some variation for my fantasy basketball team this year). He is the Thorn of Camorr, a Venice like city set in the middle ages. There is some magic going on here, but it has little to do with the story. This is the story of a group of con men, who get in deeper and deeper. The ending is extremely satisfying, and I worry about what that says about me, being satisfied by as violent an ending as I have ever read.

Red Seas under Red Skies by Scott Lynch (4/5)

Its not as good as the first book, but than again few books are. The surviving Gentlemen Bastards head to a new city, to take on the owner of the largest gambling house in the world. Than the Military Dictator of the city decides to involve them. And before we know it Lockes captaining a Pirate Ship. Badly.

The Name of the Wind by Patrick Rothfuss (4.5/5)

I don’t think I’ve ever read a book with a cooler summary at the back

I have stolen princesses back from sleeping barrow kings. I burned down the town of Trebon. I have spent the night with Felurian and left with both my sanity and my life. I was expelled from the University at a younger age than most people are allowed in. I tread paths by moonlight that others fear to speak of during day. I have talked to Gods, loved women, and written songs that make the minstrels weep. My name is Kvothe. You may have heard of me’ So begins the tale of Kvothe – currently known as Kote, the unassuming innkeeper – from his childhood in a troupe of travelling players, through his years spent as a near-feral orphan in a crime-riddled city, to his daringly brazen yet successful bid to enter a difficult and dangerous school of magic. In these pages you will come to know Kvothe the notorious magician, the accomplished thief, the masterful musician, the dragon-slayer, the legend-hunter, the lover, the thief and the infamous assassin.

Kvothe is a prodigy, and this first book is about his growing up, how he becomes an orphan on the streets, makes it to The University, and the starting of how he becomes a legend. I really liked the structure of the story, the moving from third person to first person. I was also impressed with the chapter break ups. Each chapter was a chapter. A short episode in itself. One thing that I don’t like about a lot of Fantasy novels, is the incoherent(at least to me) chapter structure. There are obviously exceptions, but for the most part it seems like authors or editors try and make the chapters more or less equivalent in size, rather than the chapter trying to be organisational. But its not the structure, its the characters that make this a great read.

So as you can see I’ve had some fun over the last few months. I cant remember such a good streak of reading, where I’ve hit no duds whatsoever.

Image from flickr

THIRST
View SlideShare presentation or Upload your own. (tags: design crisis)

SlideShare does a contest for the best slideshows created. This one won first prize this year. Thought provoking.

Take a look at some of the other winners

Lightning in Slow Motion

This just looks so cool.

Is this Schadenfreude?

I’m a big fan of Scrabulous the facebook application. Probably have 6-7 games going at any given time. Unfortunately for the Agarwala brothers, who developed it, they got sued by Hasbro for violation of their copyright on Scrabble. Real who has the rights in Europe wants to work something out, but not Hasbro who sued to shut them down. This has led to a circumstance where the game is not available in the US and Canada, but is all over the rest of the world.

I think what I feel now can only been described as schadenfreude. I am taking delight in geographical restrictions on content finally being applied to people in the US, instead of the rest of the world like it usually is. This has been something that’s annoyed me for years. The first time I encountered it was when I wanted to find out more about the Penn and Teller show Bullshit. This was years ago back in 2003, when I first heard the show was coming out, and they are a lot more international user friendly now. But while they have gotten better buying digital goods has gotten a lot tougher. I like to buy stuff, pay for stuff online all the time, but as of right now it seems like Audible is the only company selling digital media who wants my money. I miss allofmp3.com. Not Apple. not Amazon, none of the TV networks, if I want something like Heroes, or House my only choice is to Pirate it.

Ive been collecting screenshots of messages where I cant see content that Im looking for. Some are more egregious than others(Im looking at you NBC), but they all annoy me.  Here’s a slide show.

Can we handle the truth?

As a people we must ask ourselves one question: do we really have the appetite for unvarnished truth? Or is this a selective menu where only some things are palatable to us?

Barkha Dutt has a must read article in the Hindustan Times on how much truth we as the Indian Public want.

How much skepticism are we willing to apply when it comes to our institutions and the statements coming out from them?

Help the homeless



Help the homeless, originally uploaded by Balakov.

Best Nokia Phone ever?!

e71

This is my next cell phone, the Nokia E71. I had heard this was coming out a while ago, but was reminded again today when I saw a link on Mobile Crunch to an accidentally  Nokia demo, which had already been taken offline before I could watch it. I started googling a bit and found this pre release review.

It takes a lot to get us excited but the E71 has done it. This thing, in our opinion, is the best phone Nokia has made to date. That’s a very bold statement, we know. But this really is going to be the phone to beat by a lot of manufacturers. From the design, to the specs, to the size, the feel — it has the entire package.

Ive been using the E61 for almost 2 years now, and its time for a change. I was thinking of the E61i, but now I am going to wait till this ones out.